The schwarzschild solution describes spacetime under influence by a nonrotating massive sphericallysymmetric object. In a maximally extended external schwarzschild solution, that photons frequency only stays regular if the mode is extended back into the past region where no observer can go. Symmetry considerations that hold independent of the details of the emission mechanism show there is an inconsistency in the claim that such a blackhole evaporates away in a finite time. We show the maximal extension of schwarzschild spacetime in the penrosecarter diagram of fig. A physics rst approach to the schwarzschild metric 181 powers of the normally small quantity gmrc2, more than the three ingre dients sr, ep and nl are needed, which is su cient to falsify schi s claim. The blue spatial slice contains the einsteinrosen bridge connecting the two regions. Institute for advanced study department of physics. The analytic extension of the schwarzschild spacetime by kruskal coordinates. As is well known, uncharged static black holes are described by the schwarzschild solution. Symmetry considerations that hold independent of the details. Note that this new manifold m,g does not admit r as a global. Why do we care about the maximally extended versions of. Figure 7, which shows a maximum of v r at r 3gm for every l. Maximal extension of schwarzschild spacetime in kruskal coordi nates.
Really this is an extension of spacetime in two directions. White holes are predicted as part of a solution to the einstein field equations known as the maximally extended version of the schwarzschild metric clarification needed describing an eternal black hole with no charge and no rotation. However, there is another extension of region i, constructed as follows. Request pdf on jan 1, 20, andrzej krasinski and others published gyorgy szekeres 1960, the maximal analytic extension of the schwarzschild solution. Schwarzschild and kerr solutions of einsteins field equation arxiv. A mathematical derivation of the east tennessee state.
The perturbations of the exterior schwarzschild metric could be coupled to. Gravitational waves and test particles, production of gw pages 144 156 of the notes. The spacetime solution to einsteins equation that describes a universe expanding from the big bang is very similar to the timereversal of a black hole, but you dont really learn much from making that statement, especially because there is no outside. A maximally extended and regular covering of the schwarzschild vacuum is now a fundamental part of any introduction to general relativity. Motion in the schwarzschild space, schwarzschild black hole, maximally extended schwarzschild solution pages 115 of the notes week 9.
Schwarzschild solution is the unique spherically symmetric solution to einsteins equations in vacuum. I included it instead of the penrose diagram precisely because i struggle to understand the shape of maximally extended schwarzschild from the penrose diagram. This gives the socalled maximally extended schwarzschild solution m,g. The mathematical analysis of black holes in general relativity. The original schwarzschild coordinates cover only regions i and ii in fig. According to birkhoffs theorem the schwarzschild solution is also a. A careful analysis of the maximally extended metrics of schwarzschild manifold shows that the original schwarzschilds solution 1916 and brillouins solution 1923 are the only ones that are.
There were a lot of abstract concepts and sophisticated mathematics displayed, so now would be a good time to summarize the main ideas. We consider now two events a and b with coordinates xa,ta and xb,tb in o and coordinates x. Schwarzschild solution quick recap to begin, lets recap what we learned from the previous lecture. When this solution is maximally extended it has an event horizon at the schwarzschild radius r s 2m.
Notice also that the structure of conformal infinity is just like that. Carroll, spacetime and geometry general relativity, schwarzschild solution chapter 6. Kruskal coordinates to uv 0, that is either t 0 or x 0. The schwarzschild solution continued and interior solutionsstellar collapse section 5.
Mathematical relativity department of mathematics universidade. Maximally extended, explicit and regular coverings of the. Schwarzschild solution with the aim of probing the nonlinear stability of the black hole horizon. Birkhoffs theorem that states that the schwarzschild solution is the unique spherically. Material can come out of a white hole, but nothing can fall in.
This leads to the notion of a maximally extended solution. Szekeres metric shows that all maximally extended geodesics which do not. If a phenomemon p is predicted by one set of coordinates, but not by another, is that enough to say that p cannot be physical, but is observer dependent. A physicsfirst approach to the schwarzschild metric. The schwarzschild original 1916, metric equation and coordinates are chosen because they cover the entire maximally extended riemann manifold, without the problem of a coordinate singularity located at the black hole event horizon. This paper considers the effect of hawking radiation on an eternal black hole that is. The transformation between schwarzschild coordinates and kruskalszekeres coordinates is defined for r 2gm, and schwarzschild coordinates make sense.
If the submanifolds are maximally symmetric spaces as twospheres are, then there is the following powerful theorem. Almost always the covering is given by way of the implicit kruskalszekeres procedure. The wavy horizontal lines are the future and past singularities in the schwarzschild spacetime. The schwarzschild solution is spherically symmetric. The possibility of the existence of white holes was put forward by russian cosmologist igor novikov in 1964. Almost always the covering is given by way of the implicit kruskal 1 szekeres 2 procedure 3. This can easily seen from the penrose diagram, and is consistent with the fact that entanglement. The lines u 0 and v 0 r 2m correspond to the event horizon.
Again, the point is not to be able to understand the details with extreme rigor, but to grasp the. I have a question about ontological status and coordinate transformations in gr. And e is maximal in the sense that the extension problem for e has no solutions. Maximally extended schwarzschild solution, gravitational waves pages 1 143 of the notes week 10. Schwarzschild spacetime and the deflection angle the schwarzschild spacetime is expressed by the line element ds2 1. However, as emphasized long ago by ehlers 4, an explicit maximally extended and regular covering. Draw a diagram of the maximally extended schwarzschild spacetime in kruskal coordinates, and. This answer to my own question is the best example of which i know that seems to show that the maximally extended schwarzschild spacetime is of some interest other than as a purely mathematical object. On the paradox of hawking radiation in a maximally. A careful analysis of the maximally extended metrics of schwarzschild manifold shows that the original schwarzschilds solution 1916 and brillouins solution 1923 are the only ones that are adequate from the physical standpoint.
Understanding maximally extended schwarzschild solution. In einsteins theory of general relativity, the schwarzschild metric also known as the schwarzschild vacuum or schwarzschild solution is the solution to the einstein field equations that describes the gravitational field outside a spherical mass, on the assumption that the electric charge of the mass, angular momentum of the mass, and universal cosmological constant are all zero. Show that these coordinates cover both regions i and ii of the maximally extended schwarzschild solution, and that the metric of the constant time surfaces tp const is the. The penrose diagram for the maximally extended schwarzschild solution.
The globalstructure of schwarzschild isconveniently. Pdf schwarzschild manifold and nonregular coordinate. The issue of the existence of spacetime singularities was a vexing one, as emphasized particularly by john wheeler wheeler 1963, because it meant an end to the. Figure 2 shows the maximally extended schwarzschild spacetime in terms of kruskal coordinates, with the angular coordinates suppressed so that each point in the diagram represents a 2sphere. That region doesnt seem to be observable and is physically suspect, so hawking used a black hole solution without a past region which forms at a finite time in the past. In these new coordinates the diagram for the maximally extended schwarzschild solution. Sean carroll spacetime and geometry free ebooks sean carroll spacetime and geometry solutions 3. The physics of schwarzschilds original 1916 metric. Additionally the study of causal properties of spacetimes was making interesting headway zeeman 1964. Of the solutions to the einstein field equations, it is considered by some to be one of the simplest and most useful. Gyorgy szekeres 1960, the maximal analytic extension of the.
Black holes in general relativity 5 2 which is now indeed also pastinextendible. A mathematical derivation of the general relativistic schwarzschild metric an honors thesis presented to the faculty of the departments of physics and mathematics east tennessee state university in partial ful. The singularity at r 0now corresponds to tx 1 and is plotted as hyperbola with 2 branches in the 2nd and 4th region fig. Pdf on the paradox of hawking radiation in a maximally. Simplest version is the maximally extended schwarzschild solution. Embeddings and time evolution of the schwarzschild wormhole. The penrose diagram for the maximally extended schwarzschild solution thus looks like this. Symmetry considerations that hold independent of the details of the.
490 488 27 924 1409 1390 376 829 35 258 454 110 1399 164 187 875 700 726 295 269 964 536 1146 254 1061 407 1271 1474 1357 576 45